Now Servicing Lebanon and Surrounding Areas.
4.8 Read Our Reviews

Our Blog

or call us today 931-342-1149

Proudly Serving Upper Cumberland Since 1991

8 minutes read

Is It Time for HVAC Replacement or Repair? Here’s How to Decide

Published by Youtech

Your HVAC system keeps your home at a comfortable temperature all year round, no matter the weather. However, eventual wear and tear may prevent your HVAC system from functioning, prompting the question, “Do I need an HVAC system repair or replacement?”

If you are not sure, this article is the one for you. The HVAC technicians at Charles Stone have identified key factors to consider, including the $5,000 repair rule and the items that impact replacement costs.

Understanding the Basics of Your Home’s HVAC System

An HVAC system stands for heating, ventilation, and air conditioning. This system encompasses all the components and equipment responsible for maintaining your home’s heating, cooling, and ventilation.

Everyday items include your air conditioner, heater unit (such as a furnace or boiler), and ductwork. All three form a system where air is brought in, heated or cooled, filtered, and then circulated throughout your home.

Types of HVAC Systems

With your understanding of HVAC basics, let’s break down the different types of systems that are commonly installed:

  • Central Air: This is the most common type of HVAC system, found in most homes in the U.S., featuring a split system that combines both cooling and heating capabilities. The indoor unit typically contains components such as the furnace, while the outdoor unit houses the compressor.
  • Hybrid Split Systems: A more modern, energy-efficient system, designed around working in mild winter climates and temperatures. These systems contain both a gas furnace and an electric heat pump, which it switches between based on the current weather conditions.
  • Ductless Mini-Splits: A more compact split system that operates without any ductwork. Using both an outdoor unit and an indoor unit, connected by electrical wiring and refrigerant tubing, delivers heated or cooled air to specified areas of the home.
  • Geothermal Systems: Geothermal HVAC units utilize the natural temperature of the ground to deliver efficient heating and cooling through underground pipes.
  • Zone Control Systems: Zone Control systems divide your home into separate “zones” with their thermostats and sensors. With this setup, dampers installed in your ducts will adjust temperature according to the desired temperature for each zone.

Should You Repair or Replace Your HVAC System?

Breaking Down the $5,000 Rule

If you are considering repairs for your malfunctioning HVAC system, there is a straightforward way to determine if the cost is worthwhile.

Take the age of your HVAC unit and multiply it by the price of the repairs. If the total exceeds $5,000, then a replacement is the much more cost-effective choice.

In contrast, repairing an HVAC unit that is less than five years old and is generally running well is a better choice than spending a significant amount of money on a replacement.

Factors that Influence the Cost of HVAC Replacement

When considering an HVAC replacement, several factors can directly impact the cost. These factors include:

  • HVAC Unit Size: Larger homes require larger units to provide the necessary heating or cooling, meaning owners will have to pay more for a bigger replacement.
  • Home Age and Construction: Older homes may require a larger, more expensive HVAC replacement to provide proper heating and cooling. In contrast, newer homes with energy-efficient windows and insulation may need an HVAC unit with lower capacity to maintain comfortable temperature control.
  • Ductwork: The ductwork may also need to be replaced. Adding on ductwork replacement not only increases the cost of an HVAC replacement but also the time required for installation.
  • Brand: There are numerous brands to choose from for your HVAC replacement, with many offering higher-end systems. Those higher-end units, along with their branding, can come with a more expensive price tag but offer better build quality, efficiency, and a longer lifespan.
  • Energy efficiency (SEER): Higher-priced HVAC replacements come paired with a higher seasonal energy efficiency ratio (SEER) for the AC unit. This rating indicates that the new AC unit offers improved energy efficiency compared to others.

Additional Installation Expenses

In addition to the previously mentioned expenses, there are plenty of add-ons and upgrades that can be installed alongside the brand-new HVAC replacement.

HVAC companies will provide common additions like:

Signs It’s Time to Replace Your HVAC System

When your AC, heating, or ventilation equipment is past its prime, it begins to show some red flags, warning you that it’s time to upgrade. The common signs to look for include:

  • Your heat pump or air conditioner is more than 10 years old
  • Your furnace or boiler is more than 15 years old
  • Frequent repairs
  • Higher than normal energy bills
  • Uneven heating or cooling
  • Humidity issues
  • Excessive dust in your home
  • Noisy operation

Why Upgrade? Benefits of a New HVAC System Replacement

Making the big decision to replace your HVAC instead of repairs can be stressful, and at first, it may come with a fair share of buyer’s remorse. But by making the change to a new, modern AC, heater, and ventilation equipment, you open the door to benefits like:

  • Increased energy efficiency: Upgrading to a modern unit comes with being equipped with the latest technology, like smart thermostats, allowing the unit to run at peak efficiency while reducing energy consumption.
  • Improved air quality and comfort: Newer HVAC systems provide enhanced filtering, humidity control, and improved ventilation, allowing for cleaner air and consistent temperature regulation.
  • Increased home value and long-term cost savings: A brand new installation draws the eyes of potential buyers looking to avoid future renovations. Additionally, the high efficiency of new models operates with less energy waste, which translates to a lower monthly bill.

Keep Your New HVAC System Running Smoothly with Our Maintenance Membership Plan

When deciding whether to replace or repair your HVAC system, it’s important to assess its condition. If your system is older or frequently requires repairs, investing in a modern replacement is a worthwhile investment.

However, if your system is only a few years old and has been functioning well until recently, a replacement may not be necessary. In such cases, a thorough repair along with regular maintenance can help keep your system operating at its best.

And if you’re unsure about the best decision, contact the knowledgeable team at Charles Stone. Our local HVAC experts will provide a thorough assessment of your system and guide you through the various options available.

Looking to keep your HVAC working well. Join Charles Stone’s HVAC membership program. By becoming a member, you get two yearly maintenance visits and additional discounts on parts, labor, and even emergency fees. Our commercial members also receive a completely customized maintenance schedule, as well as discounts on maintenance services and parts.

Call Charles Stone today or schedule an appointment online for affordable HVAC services and more.